By Aaron McLeish · 9 min read
You see a part online for 80 quid. The same part at your local merchant is 95. Your brain does the maths instantly. You save fifteen quid, and you order it online. Job done.
Except that fifteen quid saving has a true cost you haven’t counted yet. By the time you factor in delivery time, the admin to process the order, the time you spend chasing it if it’s wrong, the hassle of returns, and the local knowledge you didn’t get, that fifteen quid might have just cost you fifty instead.
I work with hundreds of trades owners across the UK, and I see this pattern every week. The focus is always on the line item price. What it costs to buy is what it costs, they think. Not quite. The real figure is often almost invisible until someone sits down and does the proper maths.
The Price Is Not the Cost
Consider this. You walk into a merchant to buy a TRV for a heating job. You know the one you need. The counter staff know you, they know your work, they pull it off the shelf. Five minutes later you have the part. It works. It fits. It goes into the job the next day.
Now imagine the same part sourced online. You find three different suppliers. The prices range from 70 to 92 quid. You go with the cheapest. You place the order. You wait two days for delivery. It arrives. It’s close, but it’s not quite the spec you thought you ordered. You’ve got one of two choices now: take it anyway and potentially create a callback if it doesn’t fit right, or box it up, pay five quid in postage to send it back, wait another three days, and meanwhile you’re on a different job and can’t finish the first one. That callback happens anyway. You’re back at the house. Two hours of your time, the cost of fuel and van time, and customer unhappiness to boot.
The online part was 22 quid cheaper. But that true cost — the buying price plus delivery time plus the uncertainty about spec plus the time in returns processing plus the callback — ended up costing you money, not saving it.
What Are the Hidden Costs of Materials?
There’s a formula worth knowing. It comes from a conversation I had with the operations manager of a big heating business I worked with. He’d worked this out long before I did.
He explained it like this. When you buy a part, the total cost is not just what you pay for it. It’s several things stacked together:
The price you pay for the part itself. That’s the obvious one. But then add the delivery cost if you order online. Add the time you spend searching for it, comparing prices, negotiating with suppliers, waiting for delivery to arrive. And that time has a value. If you charge 50 quid an hour for your labour on jobs, then an hour of your time spent sourcing a part actually costs 50 quid to your business.
So when you think you’re saving 15 quid on a part, but you’ve spent an hour comparing options and waiting for the parcel, you’ve spent 50 quid of your own time to save 15 quid. That’s not a win. That’s accounting that doesn’t add up.
Most trades owners I know would never sit on site for an hour to save 15 quid. But they do sit at a desk for an hour sourcing cheaper parts without realising they’re doing exactly that.
Return Handling, Stock Management, and the Real Relationships
There’s more to it than just the headline numbers. Here’s what people often don’t count:
The time spent dealing with returns if a part arrives wrong or faulty. With a local merchant, you walk back in, they sort it on the spot. Online, you’re repackaging, labelling, waiting for pickup, dealing with email trails. That’s hours.
The hassle of managing stock if you’re buying online and opting for the “cheaper in bulk” option. You now own parts sitting in your van or garage for weeks. They take up space. If you buy something wrong, you’re stuck with it. A merchant holds the stock for you, and you come back when you need it.
The value of a relationship. A good local merchant knows the plumbing and heating world in your area. They know which boiler specs fit the older housing stock round your patch. They know the common problems. They can save you from ordering the wrong valve because they’ve seen this installation type a hundred times. That advice is not free. It’s embedded in their pricing. And it’s worth far more than 15 quid.
How Do Hidden Costs of Materials Affect Your Choice of Supplier?
The choice is not just price. Let me give you a real example from my own experience.
Years ago, I was working with a heating business that did large council contracts. We’d run a supplier audit, got quotes from three different merchants, and the numbers showed we could save money by mixing and matching — buy the boiler from merchant A, the flue from merchant B, the TRVs from merchant C. On paper, we saved hundreds of quid across a year.
The operations manager said no. He wanted to stay with one merchant for each contract, even though they were slightly more expensive. Here’s why. If a job went wrong mid-contract, if a part didn’t fit, if something failed during installation, we didn’t have to trawl through paperwork from three different suppliers. We went back to one place and got it sorted. The TRV already on the customer’s property came from that supplier. We could order the same thing, same spec, no guessing, no returns nightmare.
The true cost of those “savings” turned out to be higher than the merchant’s slightly bigger price tag. We kept it simple. One supplier per contract. One phone call if anything went wrong.
That’s not lazy. That’s running a clean operation where material procurement is not a headache but a system that works.
Three Things to Consider Beyond the Price Tag
Here’s what I’d actually look at when you’re choosing how to source your materials:
Delivery time and reliability. If a merchant can guarantee you morning delivery, or they’re close enough you can pick up same-day, that matters. Time to job is time to completion. That shifts the money.
Returns and dispute resolution. How straightforward is it to send something back? With a local merchant, you often get a credit note and a replacement in minutes. Online, you might be in a two-week queue.
Local knowledge and area-specific advice. This is the one most trades owners miss. A merchant that knows your patch knows the boiler systems that are standard in your area. They know the local water quality issues, the common installation mistakes, the parts that fit well together because they see them every day. That knowledge is not in the price, but it saves you callbacks.
Picture this. You’re speccing out a heating system for a 1970s semi-detached house in your area. You know from experience these properties have low water pressure and hard water. You order from a national online supplier because the price is best. You get a standard pump that’s not quite right for low-pressure systems. Install day comes. The system is undersized. Callback. Customer unhappy. Your margin on the job just got cut.
Now imagine you’ve got a relationship with a local merchant. You walk in and say, “Standard semi in this postcode, old infrastructure.” The merchant says, “You’ll want this pump instead, because of the water pressure, and this valve because of the scaling.” You never have the callback in the first place.
That’s worth money. It’s just not shown on the invoice.
Building Your Own Hidden Cost Equation
If you want to get serious about this, you can actually calculate it. Take a material you regularly source. Write down the purchase price. Add the delivery cost. Write down how many hours you spend sourcing, ordering, checking emails, processing paperwork, chasing it if anything goes wrong. Multiply your hourly rate by those hours. Add that to the purchase price.
That number is your true cost. Not the price on the invoice. The cost to run your business.
Now do it for both options — the online supplier and the local merchant. The cheap option usually stops looking quite so cheap once you’ve added the real numbers.
Let me explain where this gets even more useful. Once you’ve calculated it a few times, patterns start to show up. You’ll see which types of material orders are genuinely cheaper online because they’re straightforward, no returns, quick delivery. You’ll see which suppliers are worth paying a bit more for because they almost never cause you admin overhead. You’ll see where the real savings actually sit. And that’s when you stop relying on a gut feeling and start using data.
This is exactly the kind of operational thinking that separates a busy business from a profitable one. You can be slammed with work and still lose money if you’re sourcing materials in a way that’s bleeding cash you can’t see.
The Takeaway
There is no such thing as a cheap part if buying it cheap costs you more than you save. The price tag is not the cost. The cost is the price plus the time, plus the hassle, plus the potential for callbacks, plus the knowledge you didn’t get.
Spend five minutes thinking about the total cost of materials before you spend hours trying to save 15 quid. Choose merchants who know your world, who get it right first time, and where a phone call solves the problem quickly. Yes, they might be slightly more expensive. They’re also likely saving you money you can’t see.
If you’re serious about getting this right — really building a system where procurement is clean, reliable, and genuinely efficient — I’d recommend getting deeper into this. My book, The Systems Handbook, goes through the full framework for implementing a PO system, choosing suppliers based on more than price, and running operations that don’t leak money through gaps like this. It’s the book version of what we do at Together We Count when we work with trades businesses to tighten their numbers.
For now, pick one material you source regularly this week. Calculate the true cost — price, delivery, time, all of it. I reckon you’ll be surprised what the real number is.
If you want to talk through how your specific sourcing is working, or how to set up a system that stops these leaks before they start, email us at info@togetherwecount.co.uk, or connect with me on LinkedIn at https://linkedin.com/in/aaron-mcleish.
Aaron McLeish, Managing Director.
—